πŸ—œοΈ Compression β†’ Expansion (15-minute bars)

Backtest Β· 2026-04-20 β†’ 2026-07-15 (60 trading days) Β· top-60 liquid names chosen from BEFORE the test window Β· built 2026-07-16 Β· Trust Report
Verdict: NO EDGE β€” pass. The pattern fires constantly and loses a little bit everywhere: every tightness setting, longs and shorts, both halves of the period, and before costs.
The play tested: at least 5 fifteen-minute bars stacked inside a tight box (the coil) β†’ the first bar that closes outside the box is the breakout β†’ enter at that close, stop at the far side of the box. Long above, short below. Day trades only β€” everything closed by 4 PM. Two exit styles tried: take 2R, or ride to the close (results nearly identical).
Coil tightnessTradesWin%Avg RMedian R
Tight coil (K=1.0)88643.7%βˆ’0.03βˆ’0.20
Standard (K=1.25)2,03144.6%βˆ’0.04βˆ’0.16
Loose (K=1.5)2,78845.8%βˆ’0.03βˆ’0.11
Slice (standard setting)TradesWin%Avg R
Longs only1,04645.6%βˆ’0.03
Shorts only98543.5%βˆ’0.04
First half of the period1,04043.4%βˆ’0.07
Second half99145.8%βˆ’0.01
Longer coils (7+ bars)10045.0%βˆ’0.07
Entries 10:30–12:0017148.5%+0.02
Entries 12:00–1:30 (69% of all!)1,41044.0%βˆ’0.04
Entries 1:30–2:3045044.7%βˆ’0.04
πŸ’‘ Why it loses: 69% of these signals fire between 12:00 and 1:30 PM β€” coils mostly form at lunch, so this play is secretly a "trade the midday chop" machine, and midday chop breakouts suck traders in and die (44% win at 1:1 odds). The only slice that wasn't losing is 10:30–12:00 (+0.02R = breakeven, not edge). The coil isn't the fuel β€” it's just the quiet before more quiet.
See it on a chart: βœ… TSM 2026-04-22 β€” worked (+2R) ❌ AMD 2026-04-20 β€” typical midday failure (βˆ’1R)
Green line = entry Β· red dashes = stop (far side of the box) Β· gold dashes = 2R target.

πŸ”§ Can it be fixed? 20 variants tested (2026-07-16)

Every classic "improvement" applied as a gate on the same 2,031 signals. Fishing-expedition rules: many comparisons β€” even a green cell here would need a forward test before anyone trades it.
Improvement triedTradesWin%Avg RVerdict
Morning only (10:30–12:00)17148.5%+0.02breakeven β€” best cell, still not edge
Volume surge β‰₯1.5Γ— on breakout bar26145.2%βˆ’0.04no help
Volume surge β‰₯2Γ—9037.8%βˆ’0.17worse β€” the loud break is the trap
Big expansion bar (β‰₯1.2Γ— ATR)16042.5%βˆ’0.06no help
Box sitting at the day's high/low32939.8%βˆ’0.15worse (t=βˆ’3.0)
Breaks to a NEW day high/low43639.0%βˆ’0.16worst, and statistically solid (t=βˆ’3.9)
Only with VWAP / with day's direction1,66343.6%βˆ’0.06no help
Longer coils (6+ bars)43245.4%βˆ’0.05no help
Wider target (3R), combos of the aboveβ€”β€”negno combo with nβ‰₯100 goes green
πŸͺž The mirror test (the interesting part): since breakouts to fresh highs/lows lose βˆ’0.16R, we honestly simulated fading them (enter against the break, stop over the breakout bar, 2R target). Result: the fade loses too (βˆ’0.03 on new-extreme breaks, 32% win) β€” the initial momentum runs over the tight stop 2 times out of 3 before the reversal comes. Lunch-coil breaks chop up BOTH sides. The only fade cell at breakeven: day's-edge breaks (+0.00, n=320). Nothing tradeable either way.
The one lever this test could NOT check — and where the real hope lives: the universe. These were generic liquid mega-caps with no reason to move. James's playbook says expansion needs fuel: a catalyst, an earnings shock, SIP membership. The honest next test = same detector, but only on days the name was ALREADY in play that morning (provable-morning SIP list). If compression→expansion works anywhere, it's there — and if it fails there too, the pattern is fully closed.

⏱️ "But people made millions on this pattern" β€” yes, on a different clock

We also built the play the way the famous traders describe it (v2): only on names already moving Β±2%+ on heavy volume, coil holding the right side of VWAP, break in the trend direction, trailed instead of capped. Result: βˆ’0.31R, n=71, both halves negative β€” even worse, because in-play names whip harder intraday.

The decisive number is how far ANY coil break can run before the closing bell:
Open profit reached intradayHow often (2,031 breaks)
+1R31.5%
+2R7.5%
+3R2.1%
+5R0.3%
Biggest single run in 60 days+6.9R
Darvas, O'Neil (VCP), Minervini, Zanger traded this pattern on DAILY and WEEKLY charts, held for weeks to months β€” where a winner runs +10R to +50R. A breakout play that wins ~40% of the time NEEDS those rare huge winners to pay for the losers. On 15-minute bars the day ends before the tail can grow: the biggest winner available all spring was 7R, and only 1 break in 50 ever saw 3R. The pattern isn't wrong β€” the clock is. Same coil on a daily chart = a swing trade (different lane, testable); on an intraday chart it's at best a timing tool inside an already-working play, never a standalone edge.

πŸ“… The DAILY-scale test (the documented version) β€” the pattern wakes up

Same detector on DAILY bars Β· 2024-07 β†’ 2026-07 (2 years) Β· 300 liquid names ranked on mid-2024 data (pre-window, no survivorship pick) Β· longs only Β· exits: breakeven at +1R then ride until a close below the 20-DMA Β· ETFs purged.
CutSignalsWin%Avg RNote
All daily coil breakouts1,04131.6%+0.10positive where intraday was βˆ’0.04
Leaders only (30%+ prior move, near highs)5324.5%+0.27small sample
Leaders + volume dry-up in the coil2825.0%+0.71the full documented recipe β€” tiny sample
Non-leaders (control)98832.1%+0.09the gates do separate quality
The tails finally exist β€” this is what was physically impossible intraday: best winners +13.7R, +11.9R, +11.5R, +11.0R; on leader signals 28% reached +2R open profit, 11% reached +5R, avg hold ~12 days. Compare intraday: biggest tail all spring was 6.9R and only 0.3% saw 5R.
⚠️ Read before falling in love: (1) win rate is 25-32% and the MEDIAN trade is a full βˆ’1R stop β€” you eat ~7 small losses to catch one runner, then must hold it for weeks; (2) the top-10 trades carry ~89% of ALL profit β€” miss a few monsters and there's nothing left; (3) year 1 made all the money (+0.19R avg) while year 2 was flat (+0.01R) β€” regime-dependent, so by our own both-halves rule this is PROMISING, NOT CONFIRMED; (4) the best cells (n=28) are too small for statistics. House rule applies: a gated 2-year backtest = hypothesis. It earns a forward watch lane, not live size.
πŸ” Honesty box: universe = top-60 by dollar volume ranked on 2026-03-02β†’04-17 data (before the test window) β€” no same-day cherry-picking. Fills modeled at 15-min bar closes (optimistic on fast breaks). No commissions/slippage β€” reality is slightly WORSE than shown. One trade per name per day, first signal only. Stops honored inside bars; gaps through the stop filled at the open (honest). Trade-by-trade log: 2,031 rows, kept on file.