๐Ÿ”ฌ J3P Trust Report โ€” verify before you build

Every load-bearing claim adversarially re-checked against the source data (6 independent verifiers, each hunting the traps we've been burned by). Only build on โœ…. ยท hub ยท log
1
Confirmed
4
Weakened
1
Refuted
Bottom line (updated โ€” the verification went deeper than the first pass): the headline claim does NOT survive. The backtest only ever traded names it knew โ€” with hindsight โ€” had already moved that day; rebuild the watchlist on honest pre-market data and the out-of-sample edge falls from +0.17R to ~0. So the +0.17 was largely a look-ahead artifact, and the live SIP "diverging" from it was actually the live being MORE honest, not broken. What still stands: riding the 20-EMA beats capping the band (a relative exit finding, independent of name selection). What's now the ONLY honest measure of the real edge: the live tracker (Phase 2), capturing pre-market-selected results forward from today. Until that live scorecard proves an edge over a real sample, treat J3P as UNPROVEN โ€” trade tiny or on paper.
Does the edge survive removing look-ahead? (the biggest finding)โœ— REFUTED
NO. The backtest picks its 'in-play' names using THAT DAY'S completed move (close-vs-open โ‰ฅ3%, or range โ‰ฅ4%) โ€” which you cannot know until the day is over. It only ever traded names that, with hindsight, had already moved.
Does the walk-forward test still pass?โš  WEAKENED
The literal claim is true โ€” 5 of 6 time-blocks positive, +0.20R going forward. But it's fragile.
Do all 4 plays work on new data?โš  WEAKENED
Only ONE is statistically durable. The other three are positive but shaky, and one is basically unproven.
Is the discipline 'recipe' right?โš  WEAKENED
The end result (+0.37R with all rules on) checks out, but the recipe was oversold.
Does riding the 20-EMA beat capping the band?โœ… CONFIRMED
YES โ€” ~7ร— more on new data, and durable (holds every month, survives dropping the top 20 winners). Keep this exit.
Does the LIVE scanner match the backtest?โš  WEAKENED
The play LOGIC matches (the scanner uses the backtest's exact definitions โ€” good). But the INPUTS diverge โ€” this is the most important finding.
Nothing here is auto-executed. LAB only. Verifiers recomputed from sip90.csv / exit_variants.csv with medians, t-stats, top-N concentration, and clean-boundary split re-cuts. "Tail-driven" = the average is positive but the median trade loses โ€” show the distribution, never a single monster trade. Generated 2026-07-07.