Once you split by instrument type, RVOL stops separating winners from losers. Within megacap-tech the <1.0 RVOL bucket is the BEST (+$145.86 / 62.5% / n=16) — the exact opposite of the "calmest is worst" headline. The negative <1.0 story was a symbol confound: IBIT alone lost −$347 over 4 low-RVOL trades (including the −$216 6/3 outlier). RVOL fails even as a floor. Recommendation: D — remove RVOL from the gate; keep it only as non-gating liquidity context.
The prior audit flagged "<1.0 RVOL = worst bucket (−$320)." This cross-tab shows that loss lives almost entirely in crypto-proxy / IBIT, not in low RVOL. Control for type and the effect reverses in the good bucket. RVOL was a proxy for "is this IBIT / a crypto-proxy" — and instrument type + symbol rules capture that directly and honestly.
| Instrument type | n | Win % | Total P&L | Avg |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| megacap_tech | 51 | 51.0% | +$151.91 | +$2.98 |
| crypto_proxy_etf | 31 | 38.7% | −$179.02 | −$5.77 |
| smallcap_highbeta | 16 | 31.2% | −$113.73 | −$7.11 |
| energy_commodity n=9 | 9 | 11.1% | −$57.07 | −$6.34 |
| other_unknown | 25 | 12.0% | −$100.22 | −$4.01 |
Megacap-tech is the only net-positive type. Everything else loses — including the 25 unclassified "other" names.
If RVOL had a real floor effect, <1.0 should be worse than ≥1.0 in every type. It isn't.
| Type | <1.0 n | <1.0 Win% | <1.0 P&L | ≥1.0 n | ≥1.0 Win% | ≥1.0 P&L |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| megacap_tech | 16 | 62.5% | +$145.86 | 27 | 44.4% | −$8.33 |
| crypto_proxy_etf | 12 | 41.7% | −$292.85 | 13 | 38.5% | +$7.67 |
| smallcap_highbeta | 8 | 12.5% | −$84.87 | 2 | — | −$19.95 |
| energy_commodity | 7 | 14.3% | −$43.25 | 1 | — | −$2.50 |
| other_unknown | 10 | 0.0% | −$45.51 | 12 | 16.7% | −$44.62 |
Read: in megacap-tech, <1.0 is +$145.86 (the best, not the worst). A <1.0-avoid floor would have killed the strategy's best trades. The negative <1.0 is concentrated in crypto-proxy (−$292.85).
| Symbol | Type | n | P&L |
|---|---|---|---|
| IBIT | crypto_proxy_etf | 4 | −$347.00 |
| RGTI | smallcap_highbeta | 3 | −$38.98 |
| CVX | energy_commodity | 4 | −$33.31 |
| KOPN | smallcap_highbeta | 1 | −$28.80 |
IBIT (4 low-RVOL trades, incl. the −$216 6/3 outlier) is the entire <1.0 story. The other <1.0 trades net roughly flat-to-positive.
No consistent penalty — and cells are tiny.
| Type | >2.5 n | >2.5 P&L | read |
|---|---|---|---|
| megacap_tech | 5 | −$18.15 | mild, small n |
| crypto_proxy_etf | 2 | +$15.22 | positive, tiny |
| smallcap_highbeta | 1 | −$28.30 | n=1 |
| other_unknown | 5 | −$26.97 | small |
Read: no clean high-RVOL penalty. On all trades, the >2.5 × gap>1.5 cell is actually +$223.83 / n=27 — high RVOL is not intrinsically bad; the old story was outlier/symbol-driven. insufficient sample per cell
| RVOL ↓ / Gap → | |gap| ≤ 0.5% | 0.5–1.5% | > 1.5% |
|---|---|---|---|
| < 1.0 | −$229.31 (17) | +$29.96 (17) | −$121.27 (19) |
| 1.0–1.5 | +$41.38 (10) | −$4.43 (6) | −$60.75 (10) |
| 1.5–2.5 | +$18.65 (4) | +$80.27 (5) | −$84.65 (7) |
| > 2.5 | +$15.78 (3) | −$30.57 (2) | −$43.41 (8) |
| missing | +$117.10 (6) | +$4.97 (8) | −$31.85 (10) |
Read: the gap>1.5% column is negative at every RVOL row — gap is the real RED line. RVOL does not separate down any gap column. The one scary cell (<1.0 × ≤0.5 = −$229) is the IBIT/crypto confound again, not a calm-tape effect.
| RVOL | Fade — Win% / P&L (n) | Early expansion — Win% / P&L (n) |
|---|---|---|
| < 1.0 | 11.1% / −$400.08 (18) | 80.0% / +$55.64 (5) |
| 1.0–1.5 | 0.0% / −$103.52 (8) | 66.7% / +$53.98 (3) |
| 1.5–2.5 | 16.7% / −$56.12 (6) | 80.0% / +$4.90 (5) |
| > 2.5 | 0.0% / −$36.98 (3) | 66.7% / +$19.98 (3) |
Read: fade loses and expansion wins at every RVOL bucket. Post-entry state fully dominates RVOL; RVOL adds nothing on top of it.
Choice: D — Remove RVOL from the Green/Yellow/Red gate until a cleaner, type-controlled RVOL backfill shows it adds something. RVOL may be retained only as a non-gating liquidity/activity context readout (the legitimate kernel of option C) — never as a winner/loser threshold. The <1.0 = avoid floor is rejected (confounded).
| Option | Verdict |
|---|---|
| A. Keep RVOL as a major axis | rejected no independent signal |
| B. Demote to secondary confidence field | partial — still implies edge value RVOL lacks |
| C. RVOL only as a floor | rejected as an edge floor; only the pure-liquidity reading survives |
| D. Remove from gate; keep as context | CHOSEN |
| Layer | Rule | Status |
|---|---|---|
| RED — primary | abs(gap_pct) > 1.5% | promoted-candidate |
| RED — secondary | instrument type in {crypto-proxy/ETF, small-cap/high-beta, energy/commodity, other} UNLESS post-entry expansion confirms (megacap-tech is the only net-positive type) | promoted-candidate |
| GREEN | controlled gap (|gap| ≤ 1.5%, ideally ≤ 0.5%) AND megacap-tech AND no 3-min fade (no RVOL condition) | working |
| YELLOW | controlled gap but lower-confidence instrument type OR missing data | working |
| HARD EXIT / RED FLAG | 3-minute fade (wins ~0–17% at every RVOL bucket) | promoted-candidate |
| TREND HOLD ONLY IF | 10–15 min expansion confirmation + slope acceleration + CBO/range-break evidence if available | promoted-candidate |
| RVOL | non-gating liquidity/activity context display only | context-only |
Priority order, confirmed by this cross-tab: 1) gap 2) instrument type 3) post-entry behavior 4) RVOL only as activity/liquidity context.
<1.0-avoid floor — rejected (confounded by symbol/type)gap>1.5% RED, instrument-type axis, 3-min fade, 10–15 min expansion — promoted_candidate (pending out-of-sample)<1.0 = +$145.86 cell is n=16 (modest but interpretable); the IBIT −$347 driver is concrete (n=4, one −$216 outlier).other_unknown = 25/132 (19%) unclassified.vwap-pull-in (of 323 in the backfill).