J3P — Daily "in-play" rotation vs a static bucket

Universe = the stocks James Domino actually traded each day (used ONLY as the per-day name list — his trades/entries are NOT used). 37 names, 8 trading days (6/12–6/24), 5-min bars. Question: does playing only each day's in-play names beat trading the whole bucket every day?
Verdict
No meaningful edge from daily rotation here. In-play -0.319R vs not-in-play -0.191R vs full bucket -0.216R — the "in play today" filter did not improve J3P's outcomes on this window.
Reminder: J3P has no standalone edge yet on any universe — this only asks whether the daily-rotation selection is better than a static bucket, not whether J3P is profitable.

Headline — three ways to play the same 37 names

SIP for the day (in-play only)
-0.319R
81 trades · 35.8% win · $-2,578 (per $100 risk)
Static bucket (all 37, every day)
-0.216R
411 trades · 41.4% win · $-8,857 (per $100 risk)
Off-play (bucket names NOT in play that day)
-0.191R
330 trades · 42.7% win · $-6,279 (per $100 risk)
"In-play" = J3P only trades a name on a day James was active in it. "Off-play" = the same names on days they were not in play — the control. If the SIP idea works, in-play > off-play.

By playbook

SIP for the day (in-play)
playnwin%avg RP&L
backside_scalp450.0%+0.392$157
vwap_pull_in5639.3%-0.279$-1,564
trend_trade2123.8%-0.559$-1,171
Static bucket (all)
playnwin%avg RP&L
backside_scalp1850.0%+0.389$701
vwap_pull_in28840.6%-0.209$-6,015
trend_trade10541.9%-0.338$-3,542

Per day — in-play J3P results

datenames in playJ3P tradesavg RP&L
2026-06-12114+0.286$115
2026-06-15122-0.164$-33
2026-06-16128-0.388$-310
2026-06-171218-0.616$-1,112
2026-06-1898-0.297$-237
2026-06-221320-0.266$-532
2026-06-23919-0.241$-455
2026-06-2422-0.070$-14

Method

James's daily symbols pulled from his matched-trades record (account 14859) for 6/12–6/26; only the per-day symbol list is used. J3P run identically on all 37 names (constant $100 risk/trade, next-bar-open fills, conservative slippage). "In-play" filters J3P's own trades to (symbol, date) pairs James was active in. Some thin names may produce no J3P signals (need ≥25 5-min bars). Bars limited to ~14 days (karb). Full method: setups · summary · trade viewer.